“We see you have your company account with us and are calling to ask you to open a personal account too.” (Pregnant pause awaiting a Yes’) Meanwhile, the customer (a director of the company) is wondering, “Why? Why should I open a personal account with you?” And this is what I want to look at today – and get solutions to – selling to existing customers..
Because customers (even existing ones) don’t buy simply because you have asked, or said so.
Selling to existing customers—the logic behind the call
Now that scenario plays out multiple times, every day across various banks.
Looking inwards someone (usually a new don in personal banking, retail) reasons, “Your customer is also your prospect. It’s cheaper and easier to sell to existing customers. We need to be serious about increasing share of wallet (getting more business from the same customer). We are chasing new customers and yet we already have a captive market (existing customers).
“If they trust us with their business finances, they should their personal. The sales people can continue looking for new business and the customer service representatives should start calling existing customers. Get Operations to data mine and send us a database of customers with company accounts.”
Operations obliges and, voila!, produces a list with thousands of names.
When selling to existing customers meets reality
In theory this is Sales heaven. 1000 qualified prospects. But here’s the thing. At a strategic (don) level it’s a slam dunk – of course, they’ll buy.
Well, selling is painfully operational. And at this level the sales cycle kicks in; meaning, what you have is just a prospect. It’s the first step, yes, but far from a silver bullet. Effectively, this is a cross-sell—and needs to be treated as such.
Having a qualified prospect does not exempt you from the other five steps. The engagement may not be as elaborate as would be a new prospect but it most certainly cannot be this: “We see you have your company account with us and are calling to ask you to open a personal account too.”
And that’s the irony—selling to existing customers, how does it work? It works when you treat the process with the same intentionality and curiosity you would a brand-new lead.
The Service Team dilemma
Further compounding this problem, not being sales people, the reluctant (“it’s not our job and we are already overwhelmed by service work”) customer reps are blissfully unaware of what they are doing. And so, the mouth-watering 1,000 prospects yield a paltry 10 new accounts. Or, worse, none. It can be intensely frustrating.
Selling to existing customers sounds easier than finding new ones—but without skill, curiosity, and context, it becomes an exercise in futility.
Incidentally the same applies when selling goods on credit; the assumption is that familiarity guarantees a “yes.” It doesn’t—understanding does.
Data is not gold until you refine it
So, in addition to generating the data base, mine it a bit deeper. This is research that leads to proper prospect qualification. Yes, contrary to what you thought, the 1,000 were not qualified prospects yet.
Simply checking to see if the directors of the company also have personal accounts with you is one, obvious, -but not exhaustive- step. Account performance is also important. If it’s not active, the business most likely doesn’t have much need for it. And so, your bank.
Businesses open accounts for a reason and its not just to make and receive payments-at least not growing businesses.
So, part of the qualification could include categorizing the businesses. This could be biased on types, level of activity or turnover. The director of an active ‘one-man band’ business, for example, would be much more likely to agree to open a personal account, than one, an inactive corporate one.
By the way, this thinking mirrors how marketers focus on selling a firm’s existing products to new groups of customers—it’s about matching the right offer to the right profile.
The real question: How to sell a product to a customer
Whatever qualifying criteria you use, the why they should open a personal account (or any other really) still applies.
Customers don’t buy what you are selling just because you and your products exist. They buy because they have personal reasons why. Your job is to find out what their needs are and then align your engagement to the buyer’s selfishness.
By now you see the futility of that robotic line, “We see you have your company account with us and are calling to ask you to open a personal account too.” You are skipping all the steps after prospecting, and going straight to closing. Doesn’t work.
Selling to existing customers works best when you can connect your offer to their goals, not yours.
Selling to existing customers through curiosity
Now then. For each category you may have similar needs you think could be a starting point. For example, for the solo flyer it could be internal transfers are free -useful for when he pays himself.
But even with this knowledge, it is unwise to start with pushing that. Pull with curiosity instead. “I see you opened an account with us last year but it’s not been active since. Is it something we did – or didn’t do?” This approach opens space for a meaningful engagement.
Don’t be surprised if the director doesn’t even remember they still have it. After all its not the operational (their business’s active) account. They likely opened one at your bank for a reason that never manifested or did and was dispensed with. Either way its not on their radar.
To then ask them to open a personal account is pre-mature. Instead, lead with questions to ask customers when selling a product—the kind that reveal needs, frustrations, or aspirations.
Ask human questions even when selling to existing customers
Try instead, “I notice your business account has been quiet lately—how’s business going?”
That simple, human question does something the scripted call never does—it invites conversation. It shows curiosity, not agenda. From there, the customer opens up.
You may learn the business is seasonal, that payments moved to another bank, or that the company’s focus has shifted. Whatever the answer, you now have context—something a “please open a personal account” call never gives you.
Sell with relevance, not routine
When you understand context, you sell with relevance. You align value to need. For example, ““You’re using your business account to pay personal bills; would you like to separate those for easier tracking come tax time?”
Each question flows from the customer’s world, not your bank’s target. That’s the difference between cross-selling and cross-serving. One pushes a product; the other aligns value to need.
Selling additional products and services to existing customers should feel like helping, not hustling.
The real missed opportunity when-selling to existing customers
So yes, the logic of cross-selling to existing customers is sound—but the execution often kills it. Every existing customer is a potential sale—but only when you make them feel seen, not sold to. Cross-selling isn’t about pushing another product—it’s about uncovering another need.
“We see you have your company account with us” is about you. “How’s business going?” is about them. The real work lies in bridging the institutional why (“we want more share of wallet”) with the customer’s why (“what’s in it for me?”).
Only then does the conversation move from transactional to relational. Because in the end, no one opens a personal account just because you asked. They open it (buy) because, in that moment, it makes sense to them.
Check out our short courses and other services here. If you would like to have your sales team sell more, we can help. In order for us to do so we propose a free consultation meeting or a call. If in agreement please complete the form below and we will get in touch after receiving your details, none of which will be public. Thank you.
